The 10 BEST Reel Mower Review

10 Best Reel Mowers Reviews

The 10 Best Reel Mower Reviews

Today’s reel mowers have really improved a lot. However, you might still want to own a manual reel mower for various reasons. Consider this list of the 10 best reel mower reviews to find out the most recommended in the market today!

In a Glance


Editor's Choice - American Lawn Mower Company

American Lawn Mower 1818-18 is the best overall thanks to being an affordable, lightweight model. Many users also feel comfortable using this reel mower because of its accurate cutting at variable height. It stays razor-sharp for a long time, is easy to adjust, and you can set it to three different height positions. It can cut tough grasses such as Bermuda or St. Augustine grass, but only if not overgrown. You also need to lubricate it frequently for optimal use.


Fiskars StaySharp Max Reel Mower

The most versatile reel mower in this list, you can use Fiskars StaySharp Max Reel Mower for all types of grass, even the thick ones.

It provides double the cutting power of your typical reel mowers thanks to the large-diameter cutting reel plus heavier and thicker blades.

It’s also easy to push even in 50 lbs. Maintenance is minimal, and the blades stay sharp for long. With its high-quality inset wheels, you can mow your lawn using Fiskars without leaving patches at all.


American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Deluxe Hand Reel Mower

American Lawn Mower 1204-14 is your best choice if you’re looking for an affordable one. Besides being budget-friendly, it also accommodates almost all needs of every user given four different widths it offers. Pushing this reel mower is almost without effort, and the blades spin faster even with a gentle push. It has blades that stay sharp for long, is eco-friendly, and doesn’t need maintenance. With excellent compactness and built-quality, it’s one of the best reel mowers out there.


Great States - Push Reel Lawn Mower

If it’s excellent cutting power, there is no more popular than the Great States 415-16 Push Reel Mower. It does terrific in manicuring a lawn thanks to its adjustable blade height. With super sharp blades that last a long time, this reel mower is a long-term investment. It’s also easy to push, given the cushion grip that makes it comfortable to hold. Being lightweight, you can maneuver it across your lawn without a problem. It also makes the reel mower easy to store and transport anywhere.


Scotts Outdoor Power Tools - Classic Push Reel Lawn Mower

Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 2000-20S is known for its classic design and simple build. Although simple, it does feature one of the most stable builds on this list. It works excellently for medium and large-sized lawns with normal to thick grass. If your yard has wider lanes, this reel mower does even better as it cuts faster. With high maneuverability, it can access even the most inaccessible parts of your lawn. However, edging and going to spots near fences and walls are a bit difficult with this reel mower.


Greenworks - Push Reel Lawn Mower with Grass Catcher

With Greenworks 25072, you get a simple but well-designed reel mower. Still one of the best mowers in 2020, it can keep small and medium-sized lawns perfectly manicured. In terms of price, it is affordable. It is also lightweight, so storing it is not a problem. Collecting grass clippings is also convenient with this reel mower since it includes a rear bag. It can cut generous swathes of your lawn, easy to maneuver, and comes with increased stability.


Remington RM3100 18-Inch Reel Push Mower

At the 7th spot, Remington RM3100 Reel Mower doesn’t bow down when it comes to features and benefits. One of the most inexpensive reel mowers in this list, it can deliver clean, precise cuts. You can easily adjust its cutting height while the cutting width is just right for smaller lawns. It also makes it easier to use this reel mower for cutting grass on narrow spaces. It’s easy to push, steer, and store. It lessens fatigue and has a rear collection bag for excellent versatility.


Fiskars 17 Inch Staysharp Push Reel Lawn Mower (6208)

Fiskars Push Reel Lawn Mower 6208 is an eco-friendly reel mower with twice the cutting power of ordinary reel mower. With blades that “StaySharp,” you can use it for a long time. One of the things users like about it is you can easily adjust its height between 1” to 4” for better cutting. However, it doesn’t work well for cutting high grass and weeds. Thanks to the inset wheels, you can get as close to the walls and fences when mowing. It’s easy to push, can cut grasses and twigs, and has a discharge chute for the clippings.


Snow Joe MJ501M 18-Inch Manual Reel Mower w/Grass Catcher, Green/Black

Snow Joe MJ501M is a fantastic reel mower for smaller yards. Its biggest advantage is it’s so easy to push even a kid can do. It does get stuck when you have twigs on your lawn, but it’s easy to clear them, so it’s not a big problem. Its deck is resistant to rust, maintenance-free, and has a comfortable foam grip. You can adjust its height in 9 positions. You can maneuver it across the lawn thanks to two large wheels (10”) and two small wheels (6”) it has.


Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower, Gray/Silver/Green

Another handy tool for keeping your lawn perfectly manicured, Earthwise 1715-16EW stands out for having seven blades. With these many blades, this reel mower has better cutting power than most mowers. It is an ideal choice for tall and thick grass, so you can use it even for cutting grass on a farm. Its biggest downside it’s challenging to use when cutting upright and wet grass.

Manual Reel Mower vs. Gas/Electric-Powered Reel Mowers

The most significant difference between a gas or electric-powered reel mower and a manual reel mower is how they are powered. Reel mowers are almost always manually powered while the others work using gas or electricity. With reel mowers, you need to push physically, so the blade cylinder turns and cuts the grass.

Another difference between the different types of reel mowers is the direction in which the blades spin. In a gas or electric-powered reel mower, the blades spin parallel to the ground. But with a manual reel mower, the cylinder turns in a forward motion. With this, every piece of grass is trapped in the blades and the cutting bar. 

As a result, it cuts sharply and makes sure the grass is mowed down. Many homeowners like reel mowers because it does great when cutting fine weeds, especially those that grow vertically. On the other hand, you will find it is hard to use if your backyard has thick, wiry grass. In that case, an electric or gas-powered one will do better.

Advantages of a Reel Mower

With a reel mower, you will enjoy benefits such as:

  • Cheaper
  • Needs little maintenance
  • Environmentally-friendly
  • Keeps grass from getting a disease
  • Takes less space for storage or transport
  • Less noise when used
  • Better for lawn health
  • Cleaner and more precise cut 
  • Achieves lower cut, so less damage
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Free from fumes and exhaust 

Disadvantages of a Reel Mower

A reel mower is problematic because:

  • Narrow mowing swaths
  • Not for areas with a thick growth
  • Tiring to use for a 10,000 square feet lawn
  • Can result in uneven trim or patches 

Features to Consider

Blade Cutting Height

Options for this include a pre-set height and an adjustable one. You should choose the height based on the grass type on your lawn. If the grass that grows on your backyard is a short variety, a pre-set one is okay. But if it’s a tall variety, it is best to choose a reel mower with adjustable cutting height.

Number of Blades

The more blades the reel mower has, the cleaner it cuts. However, it means the machine needs more push-power from you. Consider if you have the strength for that. In any case, 4-5 blades work well with most lawns. But if it is too much for you, perhaps a reel mower isn’t suitable. 

Swath Width


The typical swath width is around 15-20 inches. With reel mowers, the wider the swath, the less area you have to mow. However, a broader swath is a lot harder to push. If you don’t have much arm strength, it is best to choose one with a smaller swath width.

Other Features to Consider

Consider models with ergonomic handles. It is comfortable to hold the machine while pushing it all over your lawn. Additionally, get a reel mower with steel blades that have a non-stick coating. Along with sealed bearings and advanced wheel assemblies, all these will make the task a lot easier for you. 


With the 10 best reel mower reviews in this article, you have a great list of pickings for your backyard. Take the time to research more about each product, consider the features mentioned above, and look for the reel mower suitable for both your budget and needs. 

Click Share

About the Author

I’m Megan Ann, mama to 2 and wife to James F. Core. I love meeting new people and hearing their stories. In this blog, I try to write useful and informative articles to help you as much as I can with my knowledge.

Leave a Reply 0 comments

Leave a Reply: